Sunday, 17 January 2010
A Chinese Bubble? Markets for the week ending 23-Jan-09
1) At its 2007 peak, the Shanghai A shares traded at more than 7 times book value. Japan's Nikkei index in 1989 peaked at 5 times. Chinese stocks has since halved in value
2) Price to earnings ratio of Chinese stocks using past 10 year average earnings (Graham and Dodds PE ratio) is 50X compared to about 15x in US
3) Residential real estate of Chinese cities is at a multiple of 15-20 times household income versus 12-15 times during Japan's real estate boom
4) Fixed asset investment as a proportion of GDP in China is currently 50% and Japan had similar growth rates then with 30-35% GDP
Finally a thought to hold:
A decrease to 10 year ago investment-to-GDP rates for China would have a disasterous effect on all emerging economies and countries exporting to China.
Eric Tan,
London
Sunday, 11 October 2009
Parallel Universes
Since March, we have witnessed a surge in the equities markets. Oil,gold, commodities are rising in antipation of a global recovery. On the other hand, bond yields are falling steadily and reports of US mutual funds are increasing net inflows to fixed income funds. In the world of forex, Australian and Brazilian currencies are reflecting the increase in risk appetite and yet Japanese Yen and gold typically reflecting a safe haven currency are at record highs.
The markets have been reflecting the inconsistent economic data with rising unemployment and recovering growth.
With a strong boost provided by Alcoa earnings, over the next few weeks, US companies is likely to announce strong earnings supported by exports and continued cost cuts, but inability to demonstrate revenue growth may result in a fall in momentum leading to a reality check for investors.
Eric Tan
London
Tuesday, 22 September 2009
A weaker dollar. Markets for the week ending 25-Sep-09
A super weak USD could risk exporting deflation to the rest of the world
since central banks around the world are now enagaged in managing the recession with a cocktail of a) quantitative easing, b) loose monetary policies, and c) low interest rates and it leaves them very little to combat a sudden appreciation of their currencies against the dollar. This could lead to a liquidity trap and result in them being unable to dig their economies out of a deflationary scenario.
Looking back into the history books, in the last 30 years the world has witnessed several instances of central bank intervention:
1985, G7 signed the Plaza accord to weaken the dollar
1987, G7 pledged to support falling dollar
1995, G7 intervened to help dollar
1998, Americaand Japan sold dollars to prop yen
2000, ECB, Fed, BOJ and UK, Canada supported the Euro.
So, does this mean we're going to see another round of central bank intervention in 2009?
Maybe. Coordinated intervention can work(as seen in the past), but needs to be consistent with changes in interest rates globally.
So why not do it straight away?
Central bankers hate to mess around with free markets, besides it's difficult to predict the precise consequences of interventions.
Eric Tan,
London
Sunday, 16 August 2009
Is the worst over for the US economy ? Week ending 14-Aug
In the US. the monthly rate of job losses in July has slowed to 250,000 from 600,000 at the start of the year, but the statistical computation of unemployment only improved because 400,000 workers dropped out of the labour force and are no longer looking for work.
So, the thing is, if the state of the economy is getting worse at a slower rate than before, can one argue that the worst is over?
I foresee that given the high rates of foreclosure in the US mortgage market and the continuing high unemployment rates, US household income is going to continue to be put under pressure and any economic recovery will be sluggish for the rest of the year.
Eric Tan, London
Thursday, 2 July 2009
US non-farm payrolls: Employers cut 467,000 jobs in Jun
Reflation efforts by governments worldwide helped boost risky assets such as commodities and equities in the last 3 months and in the process trashed treasuries and bonds.
10-year US benchmark rates rose from 2% at the start of 2009 to a peak of 4% last month, despite the Fed announcing plans to maintain its purchase plans.
Popular belief has it that the negative sentiment is drawn from the potential indigestion of a trillion more dollars of issuances bound for the doorsteps of willing investors in the coming year.
Scenario:
Say Bernanke's "green-shoots" of recovery was stunned by the high oil prices and the economic recovery widely expected by the end of this year doesn't materialise, we could once again face the swings of the oil price cycle and see bond yields revisit the 2% levels.
Eric Tan, London
Wednesday, 10 June 2009
Impact of China's rise on the world economy.
1) huge increase in global current account imbalances
2) global decline in nominal and real yields on all forms of debt
3) increase in equity risk premium (gap between earning yield on equities over bonds)
4) increase in global returns on physical capital
1 and 2 can be explained by the global saving glut, loose monetary policies, but a massive increase in global labour supply and extreme risk aversion of creditors from emerging economies explains 3 and 4.
We have seen that the accumulation of net overseas assets are entirely accounted for by public sector acquisitions and channeled principally into reserves.
The global balance of trade and economic power has been tilted by the resurgence of the Chinese economy, and this will have a large impact on global trade and growth in the future. China has already started acquiring raw materials directly by buying into companies with large reserves and will continue to do so in a larger way to secure its vast needs for growth.
We will continue to see the expansion of their growth and there will be opportunities for investors who manage to identify targets that are aligned with the Chinese interests for raw marerials.
Eric Tan,
London
Thursday, 30 April 2009
Can spending hold up?
The American economy is contracting at its steepest pace in 50 years, the government reported on Wednesday, but an unanticipated rise in consumer spending since January suggested to many economists that the worst of the recession might have passed
Output fell at a 6.1 percent annual rate in the January-through-March quarter after falling at a rate of 6.3 percent in last year’s fourth quar
Analysts are expecting that as tax breaks and government stimulus spending kick in, the decline in the gross domestic product could be cut in half by summer by federal spending and on various small windfalls for consumers
The looming question remains the severity of job losses. More than five million jobs have disappeared since the recession began in December 2007. As their wages disappear, households spend less, and business, in response, reduces the output of goods and services, cutting more jobs in the process.
Eric Tan
Thursday, 26 March 2009
PPIP: A Stampede on Thin Ice. Markets for the week ending 27-Mar
The S&P 500 Index rose more than 6% this week as hope mounted that the worst might be over for the banking system and a turn of the broader global economy is on the way.
As US released more details of its Public Private Investment Plan (PPIP), the US stock market surged 7% overnight but fears on the viability of the plan and likelihood of participation from banks were the main concerns.
My take on the new release is that the US is taking on a "do-everything-it-takes" attitude to rescue the economy and that should set the right tone for investors and stabilise the markets but ultimately it is not the pricing of the legacy assets and loans that will turn around the lack of confidence, but the greater transparency that is attached to this move that will allow the big banks to raise sufficient capital from private markets (in the range of hundreds of billions more) that will call an end to the crisis.
A couple of issues need also to be addressed to stop the economy from spiralling down further:
a) Distressed home sales: Without a clear sign of the bottom of falling house prices, risk appetite will not return. Hence, finance for viable borrowers with sound leverage need to be earmarked to help establish a floor for home valuations
b) Deleveraging of consumer : UK household savings rate jumped from 1.7% in the third quarter of 08 to 4.8% in the fourth quarter. Although rebuilding and repairs of the household balance sheet will bring balance back to the debt-fueled decades of 90's and early 2000's, the governments also need to ensure consumer credit is freed up to improve liquidty for the people. This is not to fuel another debt spending spree, but to inject consumption back into the economy and pull it out of a longer than expected recession.
Final words, Stabilisation is still not equal to Recovery.
Eric Tan, London
Sunday, 15 March 2009
Are we witnessing a possible turn? Markets for the week ending 13-Mar
Monday, 9 March 2009
Why Go Long Equities? Week ending 6-Mar
But having witnessed the sharp falls in world equity indices in the last 2 weeks, we wonder what the impact would be on hedge fund performance. HFRX reported dismal Feb-09 results for equity strategies.
It would be interesting to find out the average level of protection put on by equity-based hedge funds...
Eric Tan, London
Monday, 23 February 2009
Will supervision solve the crisis?
Today's worry: Institutions that are too "interconnected" to fail..
The last 2 decades of financial imagery and innovation, combined with globalisation has created a financial system with entities that are connected in unimaginable ways. This interconnectivity has been raised by Trichet that there is an impending need to extend regulatory and supervision oversight to "systematically important" financial institutions.
In the last century, supervisors and central bankers have conveniently and neatly grouped financial institutions into Banks and Non-banks, but the over-simplistic approach to non-bank financial institutions is now deemed to be obsolete. Hedge funds, credit rating agencies, credit default swaps, structured investment vehicles and offshore centres are areas highlighted by Trichet as requiring more regulation and supervision. The role required is likely to include more monitoring, and analysis of financial stability, developing early warning systems for risks to the financial system, conducting stress testing exercises and advising on financial regulation to improve stability.
Sunday, 8 February 2009
Markets for the week ending 6-Feb-09
Monday, 19 January 2009
How do you shrink the house of cards? Markets for the week ending 16-Jan-08
The FT economists forum was quite interesting this morning and I thought it was quite a good idea to put that in perspective with what the governments are adopting to deal with the current crisis.
Q: With the US official interest rate at close to zero, is monetary policy running out of ammunition?
People are confusing the 'level of interest rates' with the 'rate of change of the interest rates', hence are focusing on America's inability to lower interest rates further.
But cheap money itself provides a strong incentive to borrow and spend and raise discounted cashflow calculations of asset values
However,
1) There is an imperfect linkage between the official interest rates and the actual range of borrowing rates offered in the market
2) Borrowers further out in the yield curve, which hasn’t fallen as much has less to benefit (10-year US Treasury rates has fallen only 2% compared to the Fed fund rates which has fallen 5%)
3) Banks may not be in a position to lend for various reasons such as shortage of capital, dissapearance of commercial credit market
So, can ZIRP (zero interest rate policy) help ?
- Yes:
A) Central banks can push out as much base money (Issuing bonds) as they want to at close to zero rates.
B) Governments can use the money raised to buy longer dated government paper to push down the yield curve to partially address 2) above
C) The money can buy undervalued assets that are clogging illiquid markets from banks and add much needed capital to their balance sheet, addressing 3)
D) The same money can fund expansionary fiscal policies such as improving infrastructure, providing insurance or guarantees to banks and companies
But the above does not do much to fix the problems happening in the banking sector. The government wants to maintain a flow of lending to help good companies, but how can they distinguish between the good and toxic assets at the micro level.
The UK government has just announced more help for Royal Bank of Scotland this morning but short of nationalising the banking sector in the UK, the regulators are going to find their hands tied on how to shrink the banking sector to a realistic size while not fully recognising the large amounts of mis(over)-priced illiquid assets still sitting in the banking books of financial institutions that have yet to be marked to market.
Something positive
On hind-side for UK, not being part of the Euro might just turn out to be a blessing this week as the European nations in the EU battle to rescue crumbling credibility of the Euro as the Irish economy worsens and Spain's soverign rating downgrade from AAA to AA+. At the rate this continues, it is not impossible to predict a default of posibly a large European economy. (Other at risks: Greece , Italian Portugal)
Tuesday, 6 January 2009
The Psychological Profile of a Downturn. Markets for the week ending 9-Jan-09
The U.S. Economy Lost 524,000 Jobs in Dec 2008,
Unemployment Jumps to 7.2% Jan 9, 2009
Non Farm Payrolls declined by -524,000 in Dec 2008. Oct and Nov job losses revised up to -584k and -423k.
Unemployment rate rose from 6.8% to 7.2% (15-yr high).
Total 2.6 mn jobs were lost in 2008 (most since World War II).
Households Survey: 806,000 jobs lost in Dec; 3 mn in 2008 (most since 1945)
Continued job losses in manufacturing (-149k), construction (-101k), residential construction (-87k), services (-273k), finance (-14k), retail (-67k), business&professional services (-113k), leisure services (-22k), temporary help (-81k). Job gains in govt. (+7k), education & health (+45k)
Psychological Profile of a Downturn
The massive debt accumulation that drives up prices of assets means, that when the downturn comes, previously optimistic investors are forced to sell assets to raise money. That factor tends to make the downward spiral steeper than the upturn that preceded it. Over the past 60 years, nine of the 10 biggest one-day percentage moves in the S&P 500 were down.
Market participants hoard and protect wealth as they pay down the accumulated debt. This reduces economic transaction velocity, restraining demand for the bubble asset, further increasing the inventory oversupply. And so it goes until the inventories decline near sustainable levels, giving market participants confidence to put their money to work.
Investors look ahead to an improved segment of the economic cycle and begin to adjust asset valuations. More participants enter the fray, seeking higher returns for their cash hoards, and economic activity returns.
Sunday, 4 January 2009
2009: Still Underweight Banking? Week ending 02-Jan-09.
Sunday, 14 December 2008
Rush to Convertibles. Week ending 11-Dec-08
Saturday, 6 December 2008
US employment reaches 6.7%. Markets for the week ending 5-Dec-08.
Monday, 1 December 2008
Inversion of the 30-year US swap rate
When the yen weakens against the relevant currency, coupon rises, but the issuer can 'call' or cancel the deal after the purchaser receives a certain return.
It allowed Japanese investors to enjoy a leverage form of the carry trade, where Yen is sold to purchase more risky currencies.
However, the deleveraging of assets in the financial markets has driven Yen to record levels instead of the steady depreciation of the Yen as widely assumed by markets. PRDCs are structured such that when a certain level of exchange rate is breached, the coupon stops but the note is still valid.
With strong volatility and strengthening of the Yen, instead of the bond being called early, banks are now struggling to hedge the longer term problems of the FX exposure and currency option embedded in the PRDC bonds. This left them short in the Yen and with Yen strengthening, the problem was amplified. Dealers had to buy Yen calls or Yen spot which accelerated the Dollar/Yen downward move.
Japanese investors have sought higher returns using US swap rates and recent rally in Yen resulted in dealer having to enter the 30-year swap market to stem rising losses. This has caused the 30-year swap spread in recent weeks to fall 60bps below the yield of the Treasury bond.
Eric Tan, London
Wednesday, 26 November 2008
Update on US economic outlook
- Preliminary Q3 real GDP growth in the U.S. (revised down to -0.5% from the initial -0.3%) displayed a downward revision to personal consumption from the original -3.1% down to -3.7%.
-The U.S. housing starts plunging, Inventories remain at record highs; Home prices (S&P Case-Shiller C-10) are down 23% from the peak and the pace of decline accelerating every month
-Sudden spike in job losses and filing for jobless claims in November.
-Monthly job losses (a lagging indicator) are expected to hit the 300,000-350,000 range in 4Q08 and early-2009, taking the unemployment rate to 8.5-9% by late-2009/early 2010
-Manufacturing sector is facing tight credit conditions and slowing domestic and export demand
- Auto sector is also in a perfect storm amid slumping vehicle sales and tight credit conditions
- Recent readings of both the PPI and the CPI are showing the beginning of deflation
In a sentence: Slow economic recovery, massive erosion of consumer wealth and demand and double-digit decline in industrial activity
Actions to combat:
- President-elect Barack Obama unveiled a first rate economic team (Larry Summers, Tim Geithner and Christina Romer) to address this most severe financial and economic crisis.
- Consumer confidence got a boost from falling oil prices and new leadership in the U.S. government
- Federal Reserve announced direct purchases of $600bn in conforming MBS and agency bonds ($500bn and $100bn, respectively.)
- Simultaneously, the Federal Reserve is setting up a new $200bn Term Asset-Backed Securities Loan Facility (TALF) for investors of consumer loan-backed securities
- Government provided a $306bn rescue package for Citigroup
Next Steps:
- Significant fiscal stimulus expected over next 4-5 quarters to prevent significant growth contraction and deflation.
- Spending on infrastructure and green technology as endorsed by Obama can provide some stimulus during prolonged growth slowdown
- Democrats are also pushing for unemployment benefits and food stamps which are well-targeted and have the largest bang-for-the-buck.
- Obama has prioritized a large fiscal package as soon as he comes into office in Jan 2009